All Jar Flavors
-
Wild Honey High Protein Peanut Butter Spread
$17.99 $21.99
Ready to take a walk on the wild side, honey?
This flavor features a light and aromatic hint of summer sweet we all know and love. And, like all our flavors, it’s made from our own peanut butter base with no artificial ingredients or hydrogenated oil and fortified with high quality whey protein from happy cows.
Our peanut butters are filled with all the essential fats, complete protein, and added omegas your body needs to build and repair muscle, plus maintain a healthy metabolism.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Gluten free, non-gmo, complete protein, & low in sugar.
*This spread comes creamy without any additional toppings or mix-in’s. If you are looking for a little something extra, check out our spreads that do contain mix-ins/toppings, which are Birthday Cake, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, White Chocolate Pretzel, Chocolate Maple Pretzel, Cookies ’N Cream, and Hazelnut Blondie.
View full product details
-
-
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough High Protein Peanut Butter Spread
$17.99 $21.99
View full product details 
If you’re a cookie dough lover, (and most of us are), you’ll find that our Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough High Protein Spread 11oz Jar is one smart cookie-dough.
All the irresistible flavor of scraping the cookie batter from the bowls, without the guilt. Because, like all our flavors, it’s made from our own peanut butter base with no artificial ingredients or hydrogenated oil and fortified with high quality whey protein from happy cows and collagen protein . It’s one of our most popular flavors, which is no surprise because its dough-licious.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Gluten free, non-gmo, & high in protein.
Contains added mix ins - chocolate chips on the bottom!
-
-
Birthday Cake High Protein Peanut Butter Spread
$17.99 $21.99
Now you can have your Birthday Cake and eat it, too. With our happy Birthday Cake flavor.
We pumped up the protein to 9 grams per serving, and mixed it together with all-natural flavors, and a burst of sprinkles to add to the festivity. And surprise! You’ve got a super-healthy peanut butter filled with all the essential fats, protein, added omegas, that taste like you scooped up the leftover vanilla cake batter right off the whisk. You’re going to want to close your eyes and make a wish…for MORE!
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Gluten free, non-gmo, & high in protein.
Contains added mix-ins on top - sprinkles!
View full product details
-
-
Salted Caramel High Protein Peanut Butter Spread
$17.99 $21.99
Nuts ‘N More Salted Caramel Peanut Butter 11oz is made from only the freshest peanuts, caramel flavors, sea salt and packed with whey protein isolate and flax for added protein and Omega 3’s. As a fan favorite high protein salted caramel peanut butter is sure to please.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Gluten free, non-gmo, high in protein, & low in sugar.
*This spread comes creamy without any additional toppings or mix-in’s. If you are looking for a little something extra, check out our spreads that do contain mix-ins/toppings, which are Birthday Cake, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, White Chocolate Pretzel, Chocolate Maple Pretzel, Cookies ’N Cream, and Hazelnut Blondie.
View full product details
-
-
Cookie Butter High Protein Peanut Butter Spread
$17.99 $21.99
Our authentic Belgium windmill style cookie butter, with a homemade biscuit flavor, is made from only the freshest peanuts, genuine spices and packed with whey protein isolate and flax for added protein and Omega 3’s. With a real Gingerbread Belgium Cookie taste, make no mistake, it's far from the fructose and hydrogenated oil loaded counterpart on the market.
Gluten free, non-gmo, & high in protein.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
*This spread comes creamy without any additional toppings or mix-in’s. If you are looking for a little something extra, check out our spreads that do contain mix-ins/toppings, which are Birthday Cake, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, White Chocolate Pretzel, Chocolate Maple Pretzel, Cookies ’N Cream, and Hazelnut Blondie.
View full product details
-
-
White Chocolate Pretzel High Protein Peanut Butter Spread
$17.99 $21.99
View full product details
They say opposites attract. And our High Protein White Chocolate Pretzel is proof. It’s a little sweet and a little salty, a little smooth a little crunchy --all at the same time. This tasty concoction has a personality all its own and it is sheer delight. If your sweet tooth has been taunting you to eat better, it’s payback time; this flavor has 9g of protein, is loaded with Omegas, and it's low in sugar, too.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Non-GMO, high in protein.
Contains added mix-ins - white chocolate chips and pretzel chunks on top!
-
-
Chocolate Maple Pretzel High Protein Peanut Butter Spread
$17.99 $21.99
First of its kind, Chocolate Maple Pretzel unlocks the natural power of our high protein peanut butter formula helping you on the journey to unleash your health and fitness potential.
Just 1 serving of this high protein peanut butter contains all the essential fats, protein and carbohydrates, making it the perfect snack or meal for those serious about nutrition and fitness.
Loaded with 9g of protein per serving, added omega's, rich chocolate chunks, aromatic - all natural maple extract and savory non gmo pretzel bits, this flavor will have your taste buds doing back flips!
Put in on your favorite fruits, sandwiches or right out of the jar!
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Non-gmo, high in protein, & low in sugar.
Contains added mix-ins on top - chocolate chips and pretzel chunks!
View full product details
-
-
Toffee Crunch High Protein Peanut Butter Spread
$17.99 $21.99
Nuts ‘N More Toffee Crunch High Protein Peanut Butter is made from only the freshest peanuts, packed with whey protein isolate, collagen protein and flax for added protein and Omega 3’s.
Satisfy your sweet tooth without compromising your healthy lifestyle. The only toffee flavored high protein peanut butter, its buttery taste with unique and distinctive crunch is like nothing you've ever tasted before.Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Gluten free, non-gmo, high in protein, & low in sugar.
*This spread does have a sugary-crunch texture, but does not come with any additional toppings or mix-in’s. If you are looking for a little something extra, check out our spreads that do contain mix-ins/toppings, which are Birthday Cake, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, White Chocolate Pretzel, Chocolate Maple Pretzel, Cookies ’N Cream, and Hazelnut Blondie.
View full product details
-
-
Cocoa Hazelnut High Protein Spread
$17.99 $21.99
It's the Biggie Smalls of high protein spreads.
The first of its kind, high protein cocoa hazelnut spread.
Something sinfully sweet that loves you back and is healthy to eat.
All natural, gluten free, non-gmo, high in protein, & lower sugar than traditional hazelnut spreads.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
*This spread comes creamy without any additional toppings or mix-in’s. If you are looking for a little something extra, check out our spreads that do contain mix-ins/toppings, which are Birthday Cake, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, White Chocolate Pretzel, Chocolate Maple Pretzel, Cookies ’N Cream, and Hazelnut Blondie.
View full product details
-
-
Cinnamon Raisin Almond Butter High Protein Spread
$19.99 $24.99
The Nuts 'N More high protein Cinnamon Raisin Almond butter flavor is made from only the freshest almonds, packed with whey protein isolate and flax for added protein and Omega 3’s. Our organic raisins add a subtle oatmeal raisin sweetness to it without the worry of tons of added sugars.
Gluten free, non-gmo, high in protein, & low in sugar.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
High protein almond butter spread.
View full product details
-
-
-
-
Peanut Butter High Protein Spread
$17.99 $21.99
The originator, the og, the worlds first and best high protein peanut butter introduced on the ABC's hit TV Series Shark Tank back in 2012. Our original flavored high protein peanut butter is made from only the freshest peanuts, packed with whey protein isolate and flax for added protein and Omega 3’s.Created as the perfect snack/meal replacement, 1 serving of this power packed pb contains all the protein, essential fats and just the right amount of carbs for anyone serious about unleashing their health and fitness potential.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Gluten free, non-gmo, high in protein, & low in sugar.
*This spread comes creamy without any additional toppings or mix-in’s. If you are looking for a little something extra, check out our spreads that do contain mix-ins/toppings, which are Birthday Cake, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, White Chocolate Pretzel, Chocolate Maple Pretzel, Cookies ’N Cream, and Hazelnut Blondie.
View full product details
-
-
Almond Butter High Protein Spread
$19.99
Our high protein almond butter original flavor is made from only the freshest almonds and packed with whey protein isolate and flax for added protein and Omega 3’s.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
All natural, gluten free, non-gmo, high in protein, & low in sugar.
*This spread comes creamy, without any additional toppings or mix-in’s. If you are looking for a little something extra, check out our spreads that do contain mix-ins/toppings, which are Birthday Cake, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, White Chocolate Pretzel, Chocolate Maple Pretzel, Cookies ’N Cream, and Hazelnut Blondie.
High protein almond butter spread.
View full product details
-
-
Dark Chocolate Almond Butter High Protein Spread
$19.99 $24.99
The Nuts 'N More high protein dark chocolate almond butter flavor is made from only the freshest almonds, packed with whey protein isolate and flax for added protein and Omega 3’s. Our natural cocoa adds a subtle chocolate flavor, without the worry of added sugars.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Gluten free, non-gmo, high in protein, & low in sugar.
*This spread comes creamy without any additional toppings or mix-in’s. If you are looking for a little something extra, check out our spreads that do contain mix-ins/toppings, which are Birthday Cake, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough, White Chocolate Pretzel, Chocolate Maple Pretzel, Cookies ’N Cream, and Hazelnut Blondie.
View full product details
-
-
Coconut Chocolate Almond Butter High Protein Spread
$19.99 $24.99
Coconut Chocolate Almond Butter Spread is one of our favorite summer spreads. For a limited time only, this protein almond butter spread is composed of always fresh almonds with natural coconut flavor. It's sure to take you to the islands and back!
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Gluten free, non-gmo, high in protein, and low in sugar.
Contains added mix-ins - coconut flakes on top!
View full product details
-
-
Cookies 'N Cream High Protein Peanut Butter Spread
Sold Out
The flavor you've all been waiting for is finally HERE!
We pumped up the protein to 9 grams per serving, and mixed it together with all-natural flavors and indulgent cookie pieces. This peanut butter spread is filled with all the essential fats, protein, and added omegas, so you can have your cookies and eat them too.
Non-gmo, high in protein, and low in sugar.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Contains added mix-ins - cookie chunks on top!
View full product details
-
-
Hazelnut Blondie High Protein Spread
Sold Out $21.99
Just when you thought our low-sugar, cocoa flavored NEW-tella (see what we did there 😉) was the perfect craving crusher, get ready for this blondie bombshell.
The delectable combination of rich, creamy hazelnut spread and velvety white chocolate chunks is melt-in-your-mouth smooth and nutty, with just the right hint of sweetness.
It's perfect for spreading on toast, bagels, and rice cakes, or for drizzling over ice cream or fruit. With its unique combination of flavors and textures, this spread is sure to be a crowd-pleaser for any occasion.
All natural, gluten free, non-gmo, high in protein, & low in sugar.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Contains added min-ins - white chocolate chunks on top!
View full product details
-
-
Butter Cup! High Protein Peanut Butter
Sold Out
View full product detailsThe perfect spread for when you need even more peanut butter inside your peanut butter 😅 This one will define the true pb lovers!
Packed with protein and topped with chocolatey surprises, every spoonful is a party in your mouth. Whether you're spreading it, dipping it, or straight-up spooning it, this PB spread will have you doing the happy dance with every bite.
Filled with all the essential fats, protein, & added omegas needed for effective muscle recovery.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Gluten free, non-gmo, & high in protein.
Contains added mix-ins on top - mini peanut butter cups!
-
-
Peanut Butter Balls
$4.49
View full product detailsNuts ‘N More Peanut Butter Balls
The perfect snack for when one spoonful of peanut butter just isn’t enough 😅 These bite-sized balls pack our signature creamy peanut butter right in the center, giving you the ultimate poppable treat for true PB lovers.
Soft, chewy, and loaded with rich peanut butter flavor, every ball is a little moment of snack-time joy. Keep them at your desk, in your bag, or stash them at home for when those cravings hit — because one bite leads to another (and another).
Crafted in small batches with care, our process keeps the peanut butter smooth, fresh, and melt-in-your-mouth perfect.
✅ Gluten free
✅ Non-GMO
✅ Made with our signature Nuts ‘N More peanut butter centerNo shortcuts. No gimmicks. Just the irresistible combo of peanut butter in its most snackable form.
Pop one. Smile. Repeat.
-
-
Peanut Butter 'N Jelly Balls
$4.49
View full product detailsNuts ’N More Peanut Butter & Jelly Balls
The classic combo, now in snackable ball form. Each bite is filled with creamy Nuts ’N More peanut butter and a sweet swirl of fruity jelly for that perfect PB&J hit.
Soft, chewy, and loaded with flavor, these little balls turn snack time into pure comfort food — no sandwich required.
Great for lunch boxes, road trips, late-night cravings, or whenever you need a quick pop of peanut buttery goodness.
✅ Gluten free
✅ Non-GMO
✅ Made in small batches with our signature peanut butter centerWhy settle for ordinary snacks when you can roll with PB&J? One bite and you’ll be back for more.
-
-
Birthday Cake High Protein Peanut Butter Spread (8oz)
Sold Out $11.49
Now you can have your Birthday Cake and eat it, too. With our happy Birthday Cake flavor in a smaller, fun 8oz size!
We pumped up the protein to 9 grams per serving, and mixed it together with all-natural flavors, and a burst of sprinkles to add to the festivity. And surprise! You’ve got a super-healthy peanut butter filled with all the essential fats, protein, added omegas, that taste like you scooped up the leftover vanilla cake batter right off the whisk. You’re going to want to close your eyes and make a wish…for MORE!
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Gluten free, non-gmo, & high in protein.
Contains added mix-ins on top - sprinkles!
View full product details
-
-
Mac Daddy - Macciato Nitro Brew Macadamia Nut Butter
$18.99 $23.99
Meet the Mac Daddy of all macadamia nut butters — Macciato Nitro Brew Macadamia Butter. Crafted with rich, buttery macadamia nuts and infused with bold nitro brew coffee flavor, this small-batch spread delivers a smooth, creamy texture and an unforgettable coffeehouse-inspired taste.
If you're searching for the best macadamia nut butter, look no further. Macciato Nitro Brew combines premium roasted macadamia nuts with the indulgent flavor of your favorite iced coffee for a truly unique nut butter experience. Whether you're fueling your morning, upgrading your protein shake, spreading it on toast, or eating it straight from the jar, every spoonful delivers rich flavor and satisfying nutrition.
Unlike traditional peanut butter or almond butter, macadamia butter is naturally creamy, loaded with healthy fats, and known for its luxurious texture. Our Macciato Nitro Brew flavor takes it to the next level with a smooth coffee finish that coffee lovers can't get enough of.
Perfect for:
✔ Coffee lovers
✔ Keto-friendly lifestyles
✔ High-fat, low-carb nutrition
✔ Smoothies and protein shakes
✔ Toast, oatmeal, fruit, and baking
✔ Straight-out-of-the-jar spoon enthusiastsWhy You'll Love It:
- Premium macadamia nut butter
- Rich nitro brew coffee flavor
- Ultra-smooth and creamy texture
- Made with high-quality ingredients
- Great for keto and low-carb lifestyles
- A delicious alternative to peanut butter and almond butter
When it comes to macadamia nut butter, this is the Mac Daddy. One spoonful of Macciato Nitro Brew and you'll understand why coffee and macadamia nuts were meant to be together.
View full product details
-
-
Banana Nut High Protein Peanut Butter Spread (8 oz)
Sold Out
Some people go nuts over Nuts ‘N More. Other’s go bananas. But now everyone can go Banana Nut. High Protein Banana Nut, one of our most delicious specialty flavors.
When your craving the taste of peanut butter and bananas, you can eat this one right off the spoon. Made from select peanuts and all-natural banana flavor this high protein treat is packed with protein, flax and added Omega 3. When it comes to a peanut spread that’s both healthy and luscious, this flavor is the top banana.
All natural, gluten free, non-gmo, high in protein, low in sugar and high in fiber.
View full product details
-
-
Jack'd O'lantern - High Protein Pumpkin Flavor Peanut Butter
$19.99
Jack’d O’Lantern High Protein Pumpkin Peanut Butter brings pumpkin season to your gains. This creamy, high-protein peanut butter is packed with rich roasted peanut flavor, warm pumpkin spice, and the sweet taste of fall in every spoonful. Perfect for toast, oatmeal, protein shakes, baking—or straight from the jar. 🎃💪
Pumpkin spice just got JACK’D.
The Pumpkin Spice Peanut Butter That Actually Pulls Its Weight
Every fall, the world drowns in pumpkin spice lattes loaded with sugar and zero protein. Not here. Jack’d O’Lantern is a gourmet flavored peanut butter built for people who want the cozy taste of autumn without blowing their macros. Roasted peanuts, real pumpkin pie spice notes of cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove, and a protein boost that makes this pumpkin peanut butter a legit fuel source—not just a seasonal gimmick.
Why You’ll Get Hooked
- High protein peanut butter – more protein per spoonful to power your workouts, recovery, and busy mornings
- Real fall flavor – warm pumpkin spice blended into smooth, roasted peanut butter
- Creamy, spreadable texture – swirls into oats, blends into shakes, spreads on anything
- Limited edition seasonal flavor – here for pumpkin season, gone when it’s gone
- Made by Nuts ’N More – the high protein nut butter brand that’s been flavoring peanut butter since day one
How to Eat Jack’d O’Lantern
- Pumpkin protein shake – blend a scoop with banana, milk, ice, and a dash of cinnamon
- Pumpkin spice overnight oats – stir into oats for a high protein fall breakfast
- Toast, bagels & waffles – the ultimate autumn spread
- Apple slices & pretzels – the perfect fall dip for snacking
- Baking – level up pumpkin muffins, protein balls, cookies, and energy bites
- Greek yogurt bowls – swirl it in with granola for a protein-packed treat
- Straight off the spoon – no judgment
Fall’s Best Protein Snack
Whether you’re a gym rat, a pumpkin spice fanatic, or just looking for a healthier Halloween and Thanksgiving treat, Jack’d O’Lantern is the protein peanut butter spread you’ll be stocking up on all season. It also makes a killer gift for fitness lovers, fall foodies, and anyone who lives for sweater weather.
Grab a jar (or three) of the best pumpkin spice peanut butter before the season’s over. When Jack’s gone, he’s gone. 🎃
View full product details
-
-
North Swole - High Protein Chocolate Peppermint Marshmallow Peanut Butter
$19.99
North Swole High Protein Chocolate Peppermint Peanut Butter is a sleigh ride straight to gains. Roasted peanuts, dark chocolate, cool peppermint and mini marshmallows, loaded with 10g of protein per serving. Hot cocoa vibes without the sugar crash. Spread it on toast, drop it in your oats, blend it into a shake, or crush it straight from the jar. 🎄💪
Santa's been lifting. Have you?
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Gluten free, non-gmo, high in protein, & low in sugar.
High protein peanut butter spread.
Made with added whey protein isolate for a complete protein with all nine essential amino acids, North Swole is the high protein peanut butter built for muscle recovery, hitting your macros and crushing holiday cravings. Small batch protein nut butter, proudly made in East Providence, RI.
View full product details
-
-
Fit Gingerbread - High Protein Gingerbread Spice Peanut Butter
$19.99
Fit Gingerbread High Protein Peanut Butter is the gingerbread man after a bulk. Roasted peanuts hit with ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg and clove. All the holiday cookie flavor with 10g of protein and just 3g of sugar per serving. Slather it on waffles, swirl it into oatmeal, bake it into cookies, or eat it off the spoon like nobody's watching. 🍪💪
Run, run, as fast as you can. You can't catch these gains.
Made with added whey protein isolate for a complete protein with all nine essential amino acids, Fit Gingerbread is the high protein peanut butter built for muscle recovery, hitting your macros and crushing holiday cookie cravings. Small batch protein nut butter, proudly made in East Providence, RI.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Gluten free, non-gmo, high in protein, & low in sugar.
View full product details
-
-
Almond Apple Butter - High Protein Apple Cinnamon Almond Butter
$19.99
Almond Apple Butter High Protein Spread tastes like grandma's apple pie hit the gym. Creamy roasted almonds with cranberry apple, warm cinnamon and a pinch of sea salt. 9g of protein, 4g of fiber and zero added sugar per serving. Spread it on apple slices, rice cakes, pancakes or toast, or just grab a spoon and go. 🍎💪
Cozy season. Swole season.
Made with added whey protein isolate for a complete protein with all nine essential amino acids, Almond Apple Butter is the high protein almond butter built for muscle recovery, hitting your macros and crushing apple pie cravings. Small batch protein nut butter, proudly made in East Providence, RI.
Our small batch process never introduces external heat in order to expedite the production process in any way whatsoever. Our proprietary filling methods fill our nut butters at low heat, reducing and/or eliminating oil degradation.
Gluten free, non-gmo, high in protein, & low in sugar.
View full product details
-
